I have been beginning a debate with my friend and Radix colleague Joe Zammit-Lucia about whether or not a general election is the only way out of the government’s current impasse. Quite reasonably, he suggests that the Conservative Party will never call one – to quote A A Milne, “for fear of finding something worse”.
What has given me an excuse to return to the debate are the rumours emerging from the government that, like me, they believe first, that Jeremy Corbyn’s refusal to talk to Theresa May has guaranteed that he would lose any election. Second, that this is the traditional way in which parliamentary democracies sort out these kinds of muddles and that is to call elections.
My main nervousness about it is that – if the parties continue to pretend that they behave as if they were all of one mind – then we will be no further forward. Voters might reasonably complain that they were being sold pigs in pokes.
So what is to be done? My proposal is that, uniquely, for one election only, Parliament should wave the deposit, so that – alongside the traditional parties – we can vote for a Soubry party of Tory remainers, a Moggite party of Conservative party of hard brexiteers, and a Starm-ite (either love it or hate it, like Marmite) of Labour remainers.
Nor should we pretend that the Lib Dems are any less divided. It is just that the Liberal Leavers have drifted off to vote for others. Even so, I know at least two Lib Dem MPs who seriously struggled with their consciences about Theresa May’s last vote.
Alternatively, we could keep the deposit rules in place and pay for Brexit with the proceeds.
But to be serious, government figures have been fulminating about the ‘constitutional impropriety’ of MPs taking control of the agenda, as they seem likely to do today. The real constitutional impropriety is a government that is unable to enact its business but refuses to call an election.
The election almost exactly a century ago, in December 1918, was known as the coupon election – the coupon was provided to candidates across various parties who were approved by the coalition government. Perhaps what we need now is a multiple coupon election, so that every constituency includes a candidate to make the case for their version of the way forward.
Welcome to the Radix blog in 2019! Make a new year’s resolution to help us build the intellectual foundations for a new radical politics. Sign up to get email notifications about anything new in this blog (top right hand corner of home page).